Passed bill authored by State Sen. Sarah Eckhardt seeks to broaden teacher participation in appraisal review boards by amending eligibility criteria, aiming to enhance their role in the property appraisal process, according to the Texas Legislature website.
In the Senate, 11 Democrats and 12 Republicans voted in favor of the bill, while eight Republicans opposed it.
Meanwhile, in the House, 56 Democrats and 24 Republicans voted in favor, while one Democrat and 55 Republicans voted against it.
Sarah Eckhardt introduced the bill in the Texas Senate on Wednesday, Jan. 29, during the 89th regular legislative session.
Eckhardt graduated from New York University in 1986 with a BA and again in 1998 from University of Texas with a JD.
Eckhardt, a Democrat, was elected to the Texas State Senate in 2020 to represent the state’s 14th Senate district, replacing previous state senator Kirk Watson.
According to the Texas Legislature, the bill’s official text was summarized as follows: ‘Relating to the eligibility of a person employed by a school district as a teacher to serve on the appraisal review board of an appraisal district; creating a criminal offense’.
The following is our breakdown, based on the actual bill text, and may include interpretation to clarify its provisions.
In essence, this bill amends Section 6.412(c) of the Texas Tax Code to allow a person employed by a school district as a teacher to serve on the appraisal review board of an appraisal district, despite existing ineligibility criteria that prohibit members of the board of directors, officers, or employees of the appraisal district, employees of the comptroller, and members of the governing body, officers, or employees of a taxing unit from serving. The bill aims to expand the eligibility for teachers, enhancing their participation in the appraisal process. The act is scheduled to take effect on Sept. 1, 2025.
The bill was co-authored by Sen. Paul Bettencourt (Republican – District 7), Sen. Angela Paxton (Republican – District 8), and Sen. Roland Gutierrez (Democrat – District 19), along with three other authors.
The bill received its final legislative approval on Friday, May 30, but was vetoed by Gov. Greg Abbott on Sunday, June 22.
Bills in Texas go through a multi-step legislative process, including committee review, debates, and votes in both chambers before reaching a final decision. Each session, there are typically thousands of bills introduced, but only a portion successfully navigate the process to become law.
You can read more about the bills and other measures here.
| Legislator | Party | District | Vote |
|---|---|---|---|
| José Menéndez | Democrat | 26 | Excused |
| Borris Miles | Democrat | 13 | Yea |
| Carol Alvarado | Democrat | 6 | Yea |
| César Blanco | Democrat | 29 | Yea |
| Juan Hinojosa | Democrat | 20 | Yea |
| Judith Zaffirini | Democrat | 21 | Yea |
| Molly Cook | Democrat | 15 | Yea |
| Nathan Johnson | Democrat | 16 | Yea |
| Roland Gutierrez | Democrat | 19 | Yea |
| Royce West | Democrat | 23 | Yea |
| Sarah Eckhardt | Democrat | 14 | Yea |
| Phil King | Republican | 10 | Excused |
| Adam Hinojosa | Republican | 27 | Nea |
| Bob Hall | Republican | 2 | Nea |
| Brandon Creighton | Republican | 4 | Nea |
| Bryan Hughes | Republican | 1 | Nea |
| Charles Schwertner | Republican | 5 | Nea |
| Kelly Hancock | Republican | 9 | Nea |
| Kevin Sparks | Republican | 31 | Nea |
| Mayes Middleton | Republican | 11 | Nea |
| Angela Paxton | Republican | 8 | Yea |
| Brent Hagenbuch | Republican | 30 | Yea |
| Brian Birdwell | Republican | 22 | Yea |
| Charles Perry | Republican | 28 | Yea |
| Donna Campbell | Republican | 25 | Yea |
| Joan Huffman | Republican | 17 | Yea |
| Lois Kolkhorst | Republican | 18 | Yea |
| Paul Bettencourt | Republican | 7 | Yea |
| Peter P. Flores | Republican | 24 | Yea |
| Robert Nichols | Republican | 3 | Yea |
| Tan Parker | Republican | 12 | Yea |
| Legislator | Party | District | Vote |
|---|---|---|---|
| Gina Hinojosa | Democrat | 49 | Excused |
| James Talarico | Democrat | 50 | Excused |
| Oscar Longoria | Democrat | 35 | Excused |
| Rafael Anchia | Democrat | 103 | Excused |
| Robert Guerra | Democrat | 41 | Excused |
| Jolanda Jones | Democrat | 147 | Nea |
| Aicha Davis | Democrat | 109 | Yea |
| Alma Allen | Democrat | 131 | Yea |
| Ana Hernandez | Democrat | 143 | Yea |
| Ana-Maria Ramos | Democrat | 102 | Yea |
| Ann Johnson | Democrat | 134 | Yea |
| Armando Martinez | Democrat | 39 | Yea |
| Armando Walle | Democrat | 140 | Yea |
| Barbara Gervin-Hawkins | Democrat | 120 | Yea |
| Cassandra Garcia Hernandez | Democrat | 115 | Yea |
| Charlene Ward Johnson | Democrat | 139 | Yea |
| Chris Turner | Democrat | 101 | Yea |
| Christian Manuel | Democrat | 22 | Yea |
| Christina Morales | Democrat | 145 | Yea |
| Claudia Ordaz | Democrat | 79 | Yea |
| Diego Bernal | Democrat | 123 | Yea |
| Donna Howard | Democrat | 48 | Yea |
| Eddie Morales Jr. | Democrat | 74 | Yea |
| Elizabeth Campos | Democrat | 119 | Yea |
| Erin Gamez | Democrat | 38 | Yea |
| Erin Zwiener | Democrat | 45 | Yea |
| Gene Wu | Democrat | 137 | Yea |
| Harold Dutton Jr. | Democrat | 142 | Yea |
| Hubert Vo | Democrat | 149 | Yea |
| Jessica Gonzalez | Democrat | 104 | Yea |
| John Bucy III | Democrat | 136 | Yea |
| John W. Bryant | Democrat | 114 | Yea |
| Jon Rosenthal | Democrat | 135 | Yea |
| Joseph Moody | Democrat | 78 | Yea |
| Josey Garcia | Democrat | 124 | Yea |
| Lauren Ashley Simmons | Democrat | 146 | Yea |
| Linda Garcia | Democrat | 107 | Yea |
| Maria Luisa Flores | Democrat | 51 | Yea |
| Mary Ann Perez | Democrat | 144 | Yea |
| Mary Gonzalez | Democrat | 75 | Yea |
| Mihaela Plesa | Democrat | 70 | Yea |
| Nicole Collier | Democrat | 95 | Yea |
| Penny Morales Shaw | Democrat | 148 | Yea |
| Philip Cortez | Democrat | 117 | Yea |
| Ramon Romero Jr. | Democrat | 90 | Yea |
| Ray Lopez | Democrat | 125 | Yea |
| Rhetta Andrews Bowers | Democrat | 113 | Yea |
| Richard Raymond | Democrat | 42 | Yea |
| Ron Reynolds | Democrat | 27 | Yea |
| Salman Bhojani | Democrat | 92 | Yea |
| Senfronia Thompson | Democrat | 141 | Yea |
| Sergio Munoz Jr. | Democrat | 36 | Yea |
| Sheryl Cole | Democrat | 46 | Yea |
| Suleman Lalani | Democrat | 76 | Yea |
| Terry Canales | Democrat | 40 | Yea |
| Terry Meza | Democrat | 105 | Yea |
| Toni Rose | Democrat | 110 | Yea |
| Trey Martinez Fischer | Democrat | 116 | Yea |
| Venton Jones | Democrat | 100 | Yea |
| Vikki Goodwin | Democrat | 47 | Yea |
| Vincent Perez | Democrat | 77 | Yea |
| Yvonne Davis | Democrat | 111 | Yea |
| Charles Cunningham | Republican | 127 | Absent |
| Cole Hefner | Republican | 5 | Absent |
| Greg Bonnen | Republican | 24 | Absent |
| Keith Bell | Republican | 4 | Absent |
| Will Metcalf | Republican | 16 | Absent |
| Cody Harris | Republican | 8 | Excused |
| Helen Kerwin | Republican | 58 | Excused |
| A.J. Louderback | Republican | 30 | Nea |
| Alan Schoolcraft | Republican | 44 | Nea |
| Andy Hopper | Republican | 64 | Nea |
| Ben Bumgarner | Republican | 63 | Nea |
| Brent Money | Republican | 2 | Nea |
| Brian E. Harrison | Republican | 10 | Nea |
| Briscoe Cain | Republican | 128 | Nea |
| Carl Tepper | Republican | 84 | Nea |
| Caroline Harris Davila | Republican | 52 | Nea |
| Carrie Isaac | Republican | 73 | Nea |
| Cecil Bell Jr. | Republican | 3 | Nea |
| Cody Vasut | Republican | 25 | Nea |
| Daniel Alders | Republican | 6 | Nea |
| David Cook | Republican | 96 | Nea |
| David Lowe | Republican | 91 | Nea |
| David Spiller | Republican | 68 | Nea |
| Dennis Paul | Republican | 129 | Nea |
| Don McLaughlin | Republican | 80 | Nea |
| Ellen Troxclair | Republican | 19 | Nea |
| Gary Gates | Republican | 28 | Nea |
| Giovanni Capriglione | Republican | 98 | Nea |
| Hillary Hickland | Republican | 55 | Nea |
| J.M. Lozano | Republican | 43 | Nea |
| James Frank | Republican | 69 | Nea |
| Janis Holt | Republican | 18 | Nea |
| Jared Patterson | Republican | 106 | Nea |
| Jay Dean | Republican | 7 | Nea |
| Joanne Shofner | Republican | 11 | Nea |
| John Lujan | Republican | 118 | Nea |
| John Smithee | Republican | 86 | Nea |
| Katrina Pierson | Republican | 33 | Nea |
| Keresa Richardson | Republican | 61 | Nea |
| Lacey Hull | Republican | 138 | Nea |
| Mano Deayala | Republican | 133 | Nea |
| Marc LaHood | Republican | 121 | Nea |
| Mark Dorazio | Republican | 122 | Nea |
| Matt Morgan | Republican | 26 | Nea |
| Matt Shaheen | Republican | 66 | Nea |
| Mike Olcott | Republican | 60 | Nea |
| Mike Schofield | Republican | 132 | Nea |
| Mitch Little | Republican | 65 | Nea |
| Nate Schatzline | Republican | 93 | Nea |
| Pat Curry | Republican | 56 | Nea |
| Richard Hayes | Republican | 57 | Nea |
| Shelby Slawson | Republican | 59 | Nea |
| Shelley Luther | Republican | 62 | Nea |
| Stan Gerdes | Republican | 17 | Nea |
| Steve Toth | Republican | 15 | Nea |
| Terri Leo-Wilson | Republican | 23 | Nea |
| Tom Craddick | Republican | 82 | Nea |
| Tom Oliverson | Republican | 130 | Nea |
| Tony Tinderholt | Republican | 94 | Nea |
| Trey Wharton | Republican | 12 | Nea |
| Valoree Swanson | Republican | 150 | Nea |
| Wesley Virdell | Republican | 53 | Nea |
| Angelia Orr | Republican | 13 | Yea |
| Angie Chen Button | Republican | 112 | Yea |
| Brad Buckley | Republican | 54 | Yea |
| Candy Noble | Republican | 89 | Yea |
| Caroline Fairly | Republican | 87 | Yea |
| Charlie Geren | Republican | 99 | Yea |
| Dade Phelan | Republican | 21 | Yea |
| Denise Villalobos | Republican | 34 | Yea |
| Drew Darby | Republican | 72 | Yea |
| E. Sam Harless | Republican | 126 | Yea |
| Gary VanDeaver | Republican | 1 | Yea |
| Janie Lopez | Republican | 37 | Yea |
| Jeff Leach | Republican | 67 | Yea |
| Jeffrey Barry | Republican | 29 | Yea |
| John McQueeney | Republican | 97 | Yea |
| Ken King | Republican | 88 | Yea |
| Morgan Meyer | Republican | 108 | Yea |
| Paul Dyson | Republican | 14 | Yea |
| Ryan Guillen | Republican | 31 | Yea |
| Stan Kitzman | Republican | 85 | Yea |
| Stan Lambert | Republican | 71 | Yea |
| Terry Wilson | Republican | 20 | Yea |
| Todd Hunter | Republican | 32 | Yea |
| Trent Ashby | Republican | 9 | Yea |
| Legislator | Party | District | Vote |
|---|---|---|---|
| Borris Miles | Democrat | 13 | Yea |
| Carol Alvarado | Democrat | 6 | Yea |
| César Blanco | Democrat | 29 | Yea |
| José Menéndez | Democrat | 26 | Yea |
| Juan Hinojosa | Democrat | 20 | Yea |
| Judith Zaffirini | Democrat | 21 | Yea |
| Molly Cook | Democrat | 15 | Yea |
| Nathan Johnson | Democrat | 16 | Yea |
| Roland Gutierrez | Democrat | 19 | Yea |
| Royce West | Democrat | 23 | Yea |
| Sarah Eckhardt | Democrat | 14 | Yea |
| Adam Hinojosa | Republican | 27 | Nea |
| Bob Hall | Republican | 2 | Nea |
| Brandon Creighton | Republican | 4 | Nea |
| Bryan Hughes | Republican | 1 | Nea |
| Charles Schwertner | Republican | 5 | Nea |
| Kelly Hancock | Republican | 9 | Nea |
| Kevin Sparks | Republican | 31 | Nea |
| Mayes Middleton | Republican | 11 | Nea |
| Angela Paxton | Republican | 8 | Yea |
| Brent Hagenbuch | Republican | 30 | Yea |
| Brian Birdwell | Republican | 22 | Yea |
| Charles Perry | Republican | 28 | Yea |
| Donna Campbell | Republican | 25 | Yea |
| Joan Huffman | Republican | 17 | Yea |
| Lois Kolkhorst | Republican | 18 | Yea |
| Paul Bettencourt | Republican | 7 | Yea |
| Peter P. Flores | Republican | 24 | Yea |
| Phil King | Republican | 10 | Yea |
| Robert Nichols | Republican | 3 | Yea |
| Tan Parker | Republican | 12 | Yea |



